Island Creek oyster illustration
US East Coast Researched

Island Creek

Crassostrea virginica

The flagship of New England oysters. Briny and buttery with firm meat, vegetal richness, and a distinctive lobster-stock finish.

Brininess
Shell deep cupped

Flavor Profile

Brininess 4/5
Sweetness 4/5
Minerality 3/5
Creaminess 3/5

Primary Flavors

Finish

Long, sweet, mossy with lobster-stock savoriness

Expert Notes

The flagship of New England oysters delivers a quintessential Cape Cod experience. Strong salinity up front gives way to rich, buttery vegetal notes reminiscent of a New England clambake—sweet corn, shellfish, and salt. Raised in the cold, mineral-rich waters of Duxbury Bay and finished on the ocean floor, these oysters develop firm, meaty texture and a complex, highly segmented flavor profile with a distinctive lobster-stock finish.

Origin & Characteristics

Species
Crassostrea virginica
Native to
USA
Grown in
Duxbury Bay, Massachusetts
Size
Medium to Large (2-4 inches)
Shell Color
White and black
Meat Color
Light gray

Perfect Pairings

Best Seasons: Year-round

What Experts Say

Across 9 sources, tasters describe this oyster as:

Unique notes: lobster-stock, bisque, seaweed, citrus, vegetal

"The quintessential East Coast oyster, they're consistent yet complex, with up-front notes of ocean brine and seaweed, and a smooth, sweet finish. Deep cups encourage plump meats for a toothy, chewy bite you can really sink your teeth into. Well balanced from beginning to end."

brinyseaweedsweetsmoothchewy

"With a highly segmented flavor profile, strong salinity up front gives way to vegetal, buttery richness and a long sweet finish. These complex flavors are attributed to a life spent on the ocean floor, dug into the mineral-rich mud of Duxbury Bay."

saltyvegetalbutterysweetmineral

"Island Creeks have an amazing butter-and-brine taste. They are as salty as all getout, making them the classic Boston partner for a pint of Sam Adams Lager, and every single one is delightfully firm and beautifully clean tasting."

butterybrinysaltyfirmclean

"Midsized white-and-black shells and firm briny meat with a lobster-stock finish. Island Creek is the best known of the many Duxbury Bay oysters."

brinyfirmlobster-stock

"Rich with a bisque note on the finish. Firm meats, but petite size. They typically have an attractive, more roundish shell which is interesting."

richbisquefirm

"Briny with well-balanced seaweed flavor at a perfect level of mildness."

brinyseaweedmildbalanced

"A pop of salt faded into oblivion as the sweet, citrusy tastes within the oyster emerged after a few chews. This oyster possesses a wonderfully fresh brininess, but a clean finish. The meat is moderate."

saltysweetcitrusbrinyclean

"Medium brine, sweet, slightly meaty"

brinysweetmeaty

About the Farm

Island Creek Oysters

Est. 1992

Founded by Skip Bennett in Duxbury, Massachusetts, after an unsuccessful attempt at growing clams. For eight years, Skip was the only person growing shellfish in Duxbury Bay, a location he would later describe as 'The Napa Valley of Oyster Farming.'

Cultivation Method
bottom culture
Visit Farm Website →

History & Background

Island Creek Oysters were the first to be farmed in the Duxbury/Kingston/Plymouth Bay complex where the Pilgrims landed, which has since become a celebrated oyster region. The oyster was named by Sandy Ingber, the legendary chef at Grand Central Oyster Bar, after Skip Bennett's hometown neighborhood of Island Creek in Duxbury.

Island Creeks have been served at state dinners at the White House and can be found at several Michelin starred restaurants across the country. They won Best Oyster at the largest blind oyster tasting ever held and are the most frequently recommended oyster by servers.

Did You Know?

  • Duxbury Bay has drastic eleven-foot tides, which means twice a day the Bay drains and re-fills with cold, algae-filled water
  • At high tide, there are 35 billion gallons of water in the bay; at low tide, just 7 billion gallons
  • At any given time, there are 15-20 million oysters in Duxbury Bay
  • The name 'Island Creek' was coined by Sandy Ingber at Grand Central Oyster Bar, who told Skip the original name 'Duxburies' sucked
  • Island Creek Oysters operates one of only four hatcheries in the Northeast